Comparison: all five frameworks at a glance¶
This page sits alongside the per-framework deep pages and gives a single side-by-side view of the regulations Secruna supports. It exists for two readers: the prospect deciding which framework subscription to start with, and the practitioner who needs a quick sanity check on regional reach, penalty bracket, or known gaps before drafting an internal brief. For each framework, click through to the deep page for scope, key obligations, our coverage approach, gaps, and customer impact.
Side-by-side¶
| Framework | Region | Sector | Penalty bracket | Status | Our coverage | Known gaps | RLB-relevance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EU AI Act | EU (extraterritorial) | Cross-sector, high-risk Annex III focus | Up to EUR 35m or 7% turnover (Article 99) | Live (since 2026-08-02) | 19 rules; Annex IV export; HITL queue; audit log | EU database registration form; conformity assessment; GPAI rules pending counsel; post-market monitoring telemetry | Medium |
| RICS professional guidance | UK + 140-plus countries | Chartered surveying (RICS members) | Reputational / chartered status withdrawal; commercial gates from lenders + clients | Live (since v0.11.26, Plan 96) | 5 rules; AI Use Disclosure Statement; Firm AI Register; F1 = 1.000 | Quantity-surveying matchers v1.1; cross-jurisdiction chapter branching; counsel review of disclosure template | High |
| UK Defence AI Playbook | UK MoD operational reach (extraterritorial via supply chain) | UK defence + supply chain | Contractual: bid disqualification, contract termination, parliamentary scrutiny | In flight (Plan 99; rules + foundation shipped, marketing pending) | 6 rules; 5-tier category taxonomy; HITL routing; supplier-chain propagation rule | Defence AI Statement export; counsel-reviewed templates; marketing landing; TEVV evidence templates | High |
| Defence Standard 05-138 | UK MoD reach (extraterritorial via supply chain) | UK defence supply chain (cyber overlay) | Contractual: bid disqualification, contract breach remedies, supply-chain reach-back | In flight (Plan 100, foundation work) | Profile model on ai_systems; control taxonomy; cross-framework verdict view planned |
Per-profile control YAML pack; physical-security controls (out of reach); HSM/KMS integration; profile-recalculation UX | High |
| Secure by Design | UK central government | Cross-sector government digital services | Procurement disqualification; funding hold-back; no direct fine schedule | Deferred (Plan 101) | None shipped — design only | Everything (entity, dashboard, principle YAMLs, evidence workflow, marketing landing, counsel review) | Low |
Reading the table¶
- Region is the primary jurisdictional reach. Extraterritorial means the framework binds organisations outside the home jurisdiction when their output lands inside it.
- Sector is the in-scope organisation type. Multi-sector frameworks (EU AI Act, Secure by Design) reach further than vertical ones (RICS).
- Penalty bracket is the worst-case stated consequence. Statutory frameworks have fine schedules; professional and operational frameworks have contractual and procurement consequences.
- Status mirrors the Regulations index: live means rules fire on customer artifacts and the customer-facing surfaces are live; in flight means partial; deferred means designed but not started.
- Our coverage is what ships today against the framework, in shorthand.
- Known gaps is the explicit list of things we do not yet cover — counsel-pending items, deferred work-items, and out-of-reach controls.
- RLB-relevance flags how relevant each framework is to the first paying customer (Plan 102, RLB pilot). RLB is a UK chartered surveying firm and a UK government / defence supplier — RICS, the Defence AI Playbook, and 05-138 are all directly in scope; the EU AI Act is medium because RLB has European counterparties; Secure by Design is low until RLB enters a UK central government bid.
Where to go next¶
- For a first-time reader: How it works, then the framework matching your scope.
- For a customer onboarding under a single framework: jump to the deep page above, scope and obligations sections.
- For the engineering view on how a sixth framework would land: ADR-001 multi-framework rule book and ADR-003 frameworks as products.